Skip to content
Español
Call
Text
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Matt O'Malley
State Farm® Insurance Agent - Fishers, IN

Matt O'Malley

M O'Malley Ins and Fin Svc Inc

11844 Allisonville Road
Fishers, IN 46038-2312
Just North of 116th and Allisonville, next to the McNamara Florist.
4.9/5 average rating on Google 193 reviews
Speaking english and spanish
(317) 849-7660
Email
Call
Text
My office Office
ID card
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Matt O'Malley
Email
Call
Text
My office Office
ID card
State Farm® Insurance Agent - Fishers, IN

Matt O'Malley

M O'Malley Ins and Fin Svc Inc

4.9/5 average rating on Google 193 reviews

About me

Welcome to the O'Malley State Farm Agency in Fishers, IN! As your local State Farm Agency, we offer all the comfort of a small business with the backing of the nation's leading auto and home insurance company. At our office in Fishers, you'll find a welcoming environment and a team of insurance professionals ready to help! In this ever-changing world, our team of good neighbors are ready to help you navigate the complexities of Auto Insurance, Boat Insurance, Business Insurance, Condo Insurance, Disability Insurance, Farm Insurance, Flood Insurance, Home Insurance, Life Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Personal Articles Insurance, Pet Insurance, Rental Dwelling Insurance, Renters Insurance, RV Insurance, Trailer Insurance, Umbrella Insurance, Workers Compensation Insurance, and more!

The O'Malley Agency is a 4x State Farm Honor Club qualifier. We've proudly been serving the insurance needs of our customers throughout Anderson, Bloomington, Carmel, Fishers, Fortville, Indianapolis, Kokomo, Lawrence, Muncie, Noblesville, Pendleton, Westfield, West Lafayette, Zionsville, and all of Indiana since 2012. Some of the services available to our customers include 24/7/365 claims support, quoting & binding coverages, policy reviews, billing assistance, coverage explanations, and notary services. Are you new or relocating to Indiana? Let us help you move your insurance policies!

Matt is a faithful husband, loving father to two, and longtime resident of Fishers. He holds a Bachelor of Arts (BA) degree from Indiana University. Nearly all of Matt's time is spent between his beautiful family and owning/operating this small business, but he's also passionate about exploring national parks and coaching youth basketball and softball.

Some recent reviews from our amazing customers:

  • "Great quotes and exceptional customer service! Timely quote and new policy set up."- Paul C. (October 2026)

  • "The quote was lower than I expected. Customer service was an A+! Thanks for all you guys do!."- Reed S. (October 2026)

  • "I appreciated the time he took to explain our policy and review other insurance options."- Nancy G. (October 2026)

Find us online!

  • Instagram: matt_from_statefarm

  • Meta: Matt O'Malley - State Farm Agent

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: How do I get an accurate car insurance quote?

A: The easiest way really depends on your preference! I recommend calling our office during normal business hours and speaking with a member of our team. Or, by visiting our website to start your quote. From there, we'll contact you and explain your options, coverages, and let you decide from there!

Q: Why do you talk about liability insurance so much?

A: Because it matters! Accidents happen all the time, and our job is to help you accurately measure and assess the probability of an accident versus the consequences of an accident.

Q: What coverage is required when leasing or financing a car?

A: Leased and financed cars typically require liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage, and the leasing/financing company may need to be listed on your policy. We can easily help with this!

Q: How much life insurance do I really need?

A: Enough that your family misses you—not your paycheck.

There’s no magic number. The right amount depends on what you’d leave behind: income to replace, a loan to cover, kids to raise, debts to erase, and dreams you still want funded even if you’re no longer there to fund them. Life insurance isn’t really about calculating what your life is worth. You’re priceless. It’s about calculating what your absence would cost—and making sure the people you love don’t inherit the bill.

Q: What's included in renters insurance coverage?

A: Renters insurance can help cover your personal belongings, personal liability, and additional living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss. Matt works with Fishers residents to find coverage that fits.

Q: What protections does home insurance usually provide?

A: Homeowners insurance can help protect your home, personal property, personal liability, and additional living expenses after a covered loss. Matt serves Fishers, IN and is happy to help with your insurance needs.

Office Info

Map showing State Farm Agent Matt O'Malley's office at 11844 Allisonville Road, Fishers, IN

Location

11844 Allisonville Road
Fishers, IN 46038-2312
  • Just North of 116th and Allisonville, next to the McNamara Florist.
  • Parking: In front of building
  • Parking: Behind the building
  • No steps/stairs
Map & Directions
Speaking English and Spanish

Get a quote today

Continue a saved quote Items needed for a quote
Make a payment
File a claim

Office Info

Map showing State Farm Agent Matt O'Malley's office at 11844 Allisonville Road, Fishers, IN

Location

11844 Allisonville Road
Fishers, IN 46038-2312
  • Just North of 116th and Allisonville, next to the McNamara Florist.
  • Parking: In front of building
  • Parking: Behind the building
  • No steps/stairs
Map & Directions
Speaking English and Spanish

Insurance and Financial products offered

Call us 24/7 at (317) 849-7660

Our mission

Our mission is to help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected and realize their dreams.

Why Choose Us

Since 2012, our agency has combined the welcoming atmosphere of a local business with the substantial backing of a larger company. We are dedicated to helping people understand and navigate the complexities of insurance, not just offering policies. Our team works proactively to explain options clearly, conducting thorough policy reviews and offering prompt support with claims and billing. This commitment stems from a genuine desire to be present for people, especially when unexpected events arise.

Our approach is deeply rooted in personal responsibility and community connection. We believe in helping individuals anticipate consequences rather than simply addressing possibilities, and we are comfortable having the necessary conversations to ensure people truly grasp what their choices mean for those they care about. Choosing to work with us means joining an agency that prioritizes clear communication, consistent availability, and an earnest focus on what truly matters to you and your family.

our mission image 0

Our team

Without a doubt, the most important part to our winning formula at The O'Malley State Farm Agency is our exceptional team! We are highly skilled insurance professionals working together to fulfill our responsibility to our community. We feel a moral obligation to protect what matters most to our customers so they can focus on accomplishing their life goals. Our team is available to help you make educated decisions regarding your policies and coverages. We thrive on customer interactions, aren't afraid to have difficult conversations, and are available to help when life's unexpected events occur. Of course, we'll educate you throughout the buying experience, but that's just the beginning!

Making a difference in the lives of the people we serve, and our community has always been our top priority. Whether it's applying for coverage, discussing a claim or conducting a policy review, you'll find that our caring nature is genuine. As Matt's been saying for over 15 years, "We pride ourselves in being there for our policyholders when they need us most!"

Stop on by or give us a call and see for yourself!

our team image 0
our team image 1

Current openings

Account Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member
Fishers, IN, 46038 Full Time
Customer Relations Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member
Fishers, IN, 46038 Part Time
Please Note:

This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision, terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.

Welcome to the O'Malley State Farm Agency in Fishers, IN! As your local State Farm Agency, we offer all the comfort of a small business with the backing of the nation's leading auto and home insurance company. At our office in Fishers, you'll find a welcoming environment and a team of insurance professionals ready to help! In this ever-changing world, our team of good neighbors are ready to help you navigate the complexities of Auto Insurance, Boat Insurance, Business Insurance, Condo Insurance, Disability Insurance, Farm Insurance, Flood Insurance, Home Insurance, Life Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Personal Articles Insurance, Pet Insurance, Rental Dwelling Insurance, Renters Insurance, RV Insurance, Trailer Insurance, Umbrella Insurance, Workers Compensation Insurance, and more!

The O'Malley Agency is a 4x State Farm Honor Club qualifier. We've proudly been serving the insurance needs of our customers throughout Anderson, Bloomington, Carmel, Fishers, Fortville, Indianapolis, Kokomo, Lawrence, Muncie, Noblesville, Pendleton, Westfield, West Lafayette, Zionsville, and all of Indiana since 2012. Some of the services available to our customers include 24/7/365 claims support, quoting & binding coverages, policy reviews, billing assistance, coverage explanations, and notary services. Are you new or relocating to Indiana? Let us help you move your insurance policies!

Matt is a faithful husband, loving father to two, and longtime resident of Fishers. He holds a Bachelor of Arts (BA) degree from Indiana University. Nearly all of Matt's time is spent between his beautiful family and owning/operating this small business, but he's also passionate about exploring national parks and coaching youth basketball and softball.

Some recent reviews from our amazing customers:

  • "Great quotes and exceptional customer service! Timely quote and new policy set up."- Paul C. (October 2026)

  • "The quote was lower than I expected. Customer service was an A+! Thanks for all you guys do!."- Reed S. (October 2026)

  • "I appreciated the time he took to explain our policy and review other insurance options."- Nancy G. (October 2026)

Find us online!

  • Instagram: matt_from_statefarm

  • Meta: Matt O'Malley - State Farm Agent

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: How do I get an accurate car insurance quote?

A: The easiest way really depends on your preference! I recommend calling our office during normal business hours and speaking with a member of our team. Or, by visiting our website to start your quote. From there, we'll contact you and explain your options, coverages, and let you decide from there!

Q: Why do you talk about liability insurance so much?

A: Because it matters! Accidents happen all the time, and our job is to help you accurately measure and assess the probability of an accident versus the consequences of an accident.

Q: What coverage is required when leasing or financing a car?

A: Leased and financed cars typically require liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage, and the leasing/financing company may need to be listed on your policy. We can easily help with this!

Q: How much life insurance do I really need?

A: Enough that your family misses you—not your paycheck.

There’s no magic number. The right amount depends on what you’d leave behind: income to replace, a loan to cover, kids to raise, debts to erase, and dreams you still want funded even if you’re no longer there to fund them. Life insurance isn’t really about calculating what your life is worth. You’re priceless. It’s about calculating what your absence would cost—and making sure the people you love don’t inherit the bill.

Q: What's included in renters insurance coverage?

A: Renters insurance can help cover your personal belongings, personal liability, and additional living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss. Matt works with Fishers residents to find coverage that fits.

Q: What protections does home insurance usually provide?

A: Homeowners insurance can help protect your home, personal property, personal liability, and additional living expenses after a covered loss. Matt serves Fishers, IN and is happy to help with your insurance needs.

How to be a responsible pet owner

Consider our tips for taking care of a pet to help support their health and happiness.

Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself

To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.

Hail damage on your car: How to spot it and what to do

Hail damage can mean broken glass, dents or even interior damage. We discuss how to spot hail damage and strategies for tackling it.

What not to store in the garage

Wondering what you should or should not have in the garage? Some items may surprise you. Learn about what can stay and what to consider storing elsewhere.

View more articles

Simple Insights®

How to be a responsible pet owner

Consider our tips for taking care of a pet to help support their health and happiness.

Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself

To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.

Hail damage on your car: How to spot it and what to do

Hail damage can mean broken glass, dents or even interior damage. We discuss how to spot hail damage and strategies for tackling it.

What not to store in the garage

Wondering what you should or should not have in the garage? Some items may surprise you. Learn about what can stay and what to consider storing elsewhere.

View more articles

Social media