Skip to content

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Brian Kempiak

Brian Kempiak

March 4, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Brian Kempiak
"The customer service was great."
We responded:
"Brian, thank you for your kind review! We're grateful to have earned your business! "
Profile photo of Shannon Rivers

Shannon Rivers

February 25, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Shannon Rivers
"It is wonderful to experience, in a world where everything is going up, my State Farm insurance rates have went down. I have been a member of the State Farm family for many years. Thank you Matt O'Malley for your continued service and excellent coverage."
We responded:
"Thank you for your amazing review Shannon! Congratulations on your Auto Insurance rate decrease! More good news to come!"
Profile photo of Chris Dongoski

Chris Dongoski

February 25, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Chris Dongoski
"Matt and his crew are top notch! Always very attentive to any issues. I have my home and cars with them and have been extremely pleased. In addition, his team is always suggesting ways to save me money on my insurance needs. Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Wow Chris, thank you! We appreciate your business and are here to help!"
Profile photo of Beth McAllister

Beth McAllister

February 6, 2026

4  out of  5
rating by Beth McAllister
"Just re-established my car insurance with State Farm. Glad to be back with them and paying half as much! Matt has always been very helpful and personable. Talked with Cyla this time and she seems equally as pleasant as Matt has always been. 😊"
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and nice review, Beth! We're so happy to have earned your Auto Insurance business back!"
Profile photo of Tim Cook

Tim Cook

January 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tim Cook
"Matt Taylor WAS FANTASTIC"
We responded:
"Tim, thank you for your nice review! We're happy to be of service to you and your family for your Auto, Home, and Life Insurance needs!"
Profile photo of Luz Rendon

Luz Rendon

December 8, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Luz Rendon
"Great service, best price I could ever find out of all insurance, very nice and quick response, very much appreciated."
We responded:
"Luz, thank you for choosing us to be your Insurance Agency! We're here to help when you need! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Lincoln

Lincoln

December 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Lincoln
"Best price I could find out of all insurance companies! Also Cyla was amazing when assisting me over the phone, extremely kind, super fast and all around great service!"
We responded:
"Lincoln, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to have earned your business! "
Profile photo of Rissa _C

Rissa _C

October 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Rissa _C
"Great customer service! Listened to all my needs and made the process of getting the proper coverage I needed very simple and easy to understand."
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and review! We appreciate you! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Krista Joseph

Krista Joseph

October 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Krista Joseph
"Best insurance agency in Fishers and very personable! Thanks Matt Omalley!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and review! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Tameka Williams

Tameka Williams

September 11, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Tameka Williams
""Matt was wonderful to work with, he answered all of our questions, gave us great information and recommendations, and never made us feel pressured.""
We responded:
"I'm so glad we are able to help provide you and your family with peace-of-mind! We're always here to help and thank you for choosing us for your Auto, Home, and Life Insurance needs. "
Profile photo of wildlifers 221

wildlifers 221

September 9, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by wildlifers 221
"Matt really helped me out and explain the whole process of insurance a car I am 23 and have no idea what the hell I’m doing, but he’s guided me in the very right direction"
We responded:
"I'm so glad our team was able to help customize a Car Insurance policy that keeps you protected, and we appreciate your enthusiasm!! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Kaleb Grabert

Kaleb Grabert

September 8, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Kaleb Grabert
"Matt made the process of moving insurance super easy!"
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your positive experience, Kaleb! We're happy to help and are grateful to have earned your business. -Matt O."
Profile photo of Kathleen Valasek

Kathleen Valasek

September 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Kathleen Valasek
"Very friendly, easy communication on insurance policy review!!"
We responded:
"Kathy- thank you so much for your kind words! I truly enjoyed getting to know you and appreciated your time during our review! Please let us know if you have any questions at all! -Matt O'Malley"
Profile photo of Omar Khatib

Omar Khatib

August 19, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Omar Khatib
"Excellent customer service. Very friendly and knowledgeable. Process to get a quote and buy the policy was very smooth. Would definitely recommend."
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words, Omar! We're thrilled to be working with you for your Auto Insurance and Home Insurance!! Stop by anytime :)"
Profile photo of Its.SeanJerry

Its.SeanJerry

August 14, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Its.SeanJerry
"Very helpful and useful to explain everything needed and Matt helped me find the lowest price possible for my renters insurance"
We responded:
"We're thrilled to hear Matt was able to help you with your Renter's Insurance needs! Let us know how we can be of service, and thank you for your business!"
Profile photo of James Maschmeyer

James Maschmeyer

June 24, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by James Maschmeyer
"Very nice, responsive, and followed through on commitments"
We responded:
"Thank you for choosing the O'Malley Agency! "
Profile photo of Evan Willams

Evan Willams

June 19, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Evan Willams
"Fantastic service and friendly and helpful employees"
We responded:
"Thank you for your review, Evan! "
Profile photo of Gaven Wedekind

Gaven Wedekind

March 4, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Gaven Wedekind
"Was able to help a ton!"
We responded:
"We're happy to help Gaven! Thank you for choosing O'Malley State Farm!"
Profile photo of Susan Crow-Jones

Susan Crow-Jones

February 12, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Susan Crow-Jones
"Very friendly and knowledgeable of my needs for insurance! Kim was exceptionally awesome! Definitely will refer family and friends to them. I feel so much better being back with State Farm!"
We responded:
"We're so glad to have you back, Susan! Thank you for your kind review, and for trusting State Farm to protect your car and home!"
Profile photo of Londyn Jadore

Londyn Jadore

January 3, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Londyn Jadore
"Amazing Interaction and very informative"
We responded:
"Thank you for your review Londyn! We're here to help!"
Profile photo of Sarah McConnell

Sarah McConnell

December 30, 2024

5  out of  5
rating by Sarah McConnell
"Matt was able to save me $100 a month on my insurance costs! Thank you so much Matt and Kim!"
We responded:
"Sarah, thank you for your kind review! "
Profile photo of Zachary Aker

Zachary Aker

December 30, 2024

5  out of  5
rating by Zachary Aker
"Fast and easy to work with!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your review, Zachary! We appreciate your business!"
Profile photo of Scot Reeder

Scot Reeder

December 16, 2024

5  out of  5
rating by Scot Reeder
"Very wonderful office and staff to deal with. Would recommend using them for all your insurance needs. I just moved my homeowners insurance over with no complications. Now I am a multiple policy customer."
We responded:
"Scot, thank you for your kind review and for your business! We truly appreciate working with you to provide you both Car Insurance and Home Insurance! As you saw, when you bundle your policies, you certainly earn a great rate with State Farm!"
Profile photo of chris keller

chris keller

November 24, 2024

5  out of  5
rating by chris keller
"Matt is always there for us. When I got hit in my car and it was judged not my fault, he still kept track of things to .ske sure I was treated well. Annual reviews on homeowners policies are always done to be sure I have coverage I need and none that I don't need. This is a top notch first class customer focused agent. He is also a friend that I made when he became my agent after a move into Fishers."
We responded:
"Thank you for your amazing review, Chris! I'm so glad to hear you've been happy with our handling of your claims experience! We are grateful for your business! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Aaron Miller

Aaron Miller

November 22, 2024

5  out of  5
rating by Aaron Miller
"Matt was eager to help, got me taken care of quickly and efficiently. Painless transaction."
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words, and business! We're here to help! -Matt O."